by Mei Wen,Fong, Counseling Psychologist
The Cultural Background of Self-Reflection
Self-reflection is deeply embedded in Chinese culture. From a young age, we are taught to reflect on our actions to improve ourselves, reduce mistakes, and correct them promptly. If we make a mistake, we must learn to apologize. As such, self-reflection has long been regarded as a virtuous practice, ingrained in our education and culture.
Common Reactions to Criticism
Shame and Retaliation
When we make mistakes, we often feel ashamed, or sometimes even angry. For example, if Person A is reminded by Person B about an inappropriate action, Person A might respond with anger or even escalate the situation into a conflict. This phenomenon discourages many people from offering corrections, fearing an intense reaction.
In moments of shame, we may wish to hide, as if we could disappear into a hole to escape the gaze of others. However, when the shame becomes overwhelming, some might choose to retaliate, feeling cornered with no other option. Such retaliation often leads to regret, as the intent was never to hurt others.
Suppressed Anger and Resentment
Others might refrain from retaliating but harbor anger internally, questioning the rudeness or insensitivity of the other party. Thoughts like, "I treat you with respect, so why are you speaking so harshly?" may arise. While the decision to distance oneself from the other party is made, the anger often lingers, even after venting to friends.
The Endless Replay of Hurtful Words
Some people find themselves stuck in a mental loop, replaying the critical words of others. Like a broken radio, the thoughts repeat uncontrollably, leaving them feeling deeply upset and unable to move on.
The Vicious Cycle of Overthinking in Self-Reflection
We may find ourselves cycling through these reactions repeatedly, trying to maintain harmony with others while struggling with interpersonal conflicts. Each time someone says something hurtful, the same emotions resurface, trapping us in a never-ending loop.
Before delving into the root causes, it's important to acknowledge that sometimes criticism can indeed be excessive or bullying in nature. In such cases, the issue lies with the critic rather than ourselves. Nonetheless, it's vital to distinguish between external and internal factors and approach our emotions rationally.
The Impact of Overthinking in Self-Reflection
The Link Between Criticism and Emotion
When criticized, we often reflexively engage in self-reflection. Statements like:
- "Why did you handle it like that?"
- "You’re late again."
- "You forgot to send me the file—don’t let it happen again."
- "Why didn’t you inform me after completing the task?"
- "Are you even listening to me?"
- "You promised to deliver this last week, and it’s still not done."
- "You won’t succeed if you keep working this way."
- "Do you think this approach to discussion is appropriate?"
...are easily interpreted as blame. This reaction is deeply ingrained, as we learned early on to read adults’ facial expressions and understand the implication: "I did something wrong and must reflect to improve."
The Amplification of Self-Blame
As children, we may have experienced more severe criticisms, such as:
- "Don’t you know I’m doing this for your own good?"
- "You’re such a hassle—do you realize the trouble your mistakes cause me?"
Without the tools to process these emotions, we internalized them, striving to avoid mistakes to escape further reprimand. Over time, these emotions became a part of us, surfacing as automatic reactions in adulthood.
Now, when we hear similar criticisms, we often amplify the self-reproach:
- "You’re so stupid—how could you mess up again?"
- "You’ll lose your job, and no one will like you."
This harsh internal dialogue deepens feelings of shame, sadness, and self-loathing.
Breaking the Cycle of Overthinking in Self-Reflection
Identifying the Problem and Adjusting Perspective
When criticism leaves us feeling overly distressed, we can ask ourselves:
- Am I linking this experience to past events?
- Are the criticisms objective and factual?
- Could there be unique circumstances at play?
These questions help us differentiate between external reality and internalized self-blame. If we recognize that we’re overreacting, we can remind ourselves:
- This situation is different from the past.
- The person criticizing me is not the same as those in my childhood.
- What can I do now to address this issue constructively?
Regaining Inner Freedom
By consistently practicing these techniques, we can awaken to the present and free ourselves from the shadows of the past. Gradually, we can shift our automatic reactions and embrace a more liberated, joyful way of life.
